Kioto wrote:
Back on topic,
I think its harsh to say the NewGen FF's lack storyline.
I've had nothing but good times playing pretty much all FF's.
I really want to play FFX though, i haven't to date.
They have storylines, just nothing compared to the originals. The originals had to rely on composed music, battle setups, and real plot lines to develope their storylines. The new age ones just used fancy CG scenes to make it all sound awesome. Compared to other games, the new age FFs have amazing storylines, compared to their predescors with nintendo, their storylines are garbage. The whole Aeris dying shit was almost a complete rip from the previous general leo dying, but it was done with Cg to make it more dramatic... meanwhile when I think of character being killed off that were memorable. I think of the genral leo thing first. Maybe it was because you thought he was the man, maybe bcause he was being setup as the sympathiser who might help you stop the emperor, maybe it was the fact that when he died all the esper came to his rescue, maybe it was the fact kefka commited genocide on all those espers right after killing him... just maybe its because it made so much more sense to kill general leo like that.
All I know I've always been disappointed with the new FFs storylines, until the very end, when they blow their big "oh my god" load all over your tv screen. I'm not the only one with the opinion either, its said everywhere, even by relevalent gaming magazines and shows. Its not like the games are horrible, is just they have lost that luster they had with the original grandfather games. I'm hoping this one has a chance, it will be a welcome detachment from take "random guy A" and give him a sword and have him become a hero.
Put it this way, Secret of Mana, not a FF game, but a square game. Was amazing in its hayday, downright in my opinion one of the best rpgs ever made, and one of the best snes rpgs ever made. Every single mana game made after wards, is garbage! You know why you can tell their garbage, they have almost no CG. Square concentrates all their CG artist on the FF franchise, leaving mana franchise to the basics, without the good storylines, you end up with the crap we see now in the mana series.
I never did the research, but I can almost bet money that some writer or writers stopped working at square around the same time they made ff7. Its the only way to explain the sudden drop in story quality from my viewpoint.